"We are back" « oc.at

Radeon 9600 XT Review

JC 15.10.2003 - 16:21 796 1
Posts

JC

Vereinsmitglied
Disruptor
Avatar
Registered: Feb 2001
Location: Katratzi
Posts: 9066
Review @ Beyond3D
Zitat
The one potential weakness that the 9600 XT may show in a competitive environment is that of the memory choice. Clearly ATI have targeted the board at a very competitive mainstream price, and the choice of memory speed is probably due to cost constraints to meet this price. There will be some situations, such as those titles that rely on more fixed function processing, or heavy FSAA use, where plenty of bandwidth is still a large requirement, however under heavy shader use situations, when the operations are ALU bound, the computational power, of which speed is a large factor, becomes more important. This is potentially a risky move for ATI as it may be difficult to show the 9600 XT in its best light with the mix of games and tiles being used and benchmarked as the mix of shader usage in games and benchmarks is still relatively low.

All in all, though, the Radeon 9600 XT does its job well – it’s a small, relatively unassuming little card that handles today’s titles with ease and still has the good image quality of the rest of the R300 chip line. It manages to outperform the 9600 PRO in all cases, whilst being no more expensive than the 9600 PRO’s entry price, and finally puts it up there with the 9500 PRO in many cases

JC

Vereinsmitglied
Disruptor
Avatar
Registered: Feb 2001
Location: Katratzi
Posts: 9066
Review @ AnandTech
Zitat
The Radeon 9600 XT ended up not being nearly as interesting as ATI would've liked it to be, but it does continue ATI's success in the midrange segment. We crowned the original Radeon 9600 Pro the winner of this segment back in April, and with the Radeon 9600 XT ATI extends the lead (although the improvement is only marginal). The GeForce FX 5600 Ultra is quite disappointing when put up against the Radeon 9600 Pro and 9600 XT; although NVIDIA will tell you to wait for the GeForce FX 5700 Ultra, try telling that to those that did invest in the FX 5600 Ultra.

The GeForce FX 5700 Ultra is architecturally different from the 5600 Ultra, so there is a chance that the gap could shrink but we'll have to wait another week or two before deciding on that.
Kontakt | Unser Forum | Über overclockers.at | Impressum | Datenschutz